Fly Creek Cider Mill - Closed for Season but Open Online

By Alexis Pencar

FLY CREEK — As the winter really sets in, beloved Fly Creek Cider Mill near Cooperstown, has closed its doors for the season, however their products are still available through their new Online Store! The historic mill, which has been pressing apples since 1856, is closed but will reopen on May 9th, 2025. Cider lovers need not fret! The brand new Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store is now open year-round, offering a variety of their beloved products to be ordered right to your door!

Fly Creek Cider Mill has a storied history that dates back to 1856. The mill was originally built by Hosea Williams, who harnessed the power of Fly Creek to run a water-powered cider press. Over the years, the mill has seen many changes, including a brief closure during Prohibition and a revival in the 1960s by Charlie and Barbara Michaels. Today, the mill is operated by the Michaels family, who continue to uphold the traditions and quality that have made Fly Creek Cider Mill a beloved destination.

Fly Creek Cider Mill is known for its rich traditions, including the annual cider pressing season that begins in September. Visitors can witness the historic 1889 water-powered press in action, producing over 20,000 gallons of cider each fall. The mill has also been recognized for its excellence, winning the USA TODAY Readers' Choice Award for Best Cidery in the United States in 2024. This prestigious award highlights the mill's dedication to quality and exceptional visitor experiences.

Fly Creek Cider Mill offers a wide range of products, including freshly pressed apple cider, hard ciders, and apple wines. The Mill Store Marketplace is a treasure trove of over 200 specialty food products. Visitors can find sparkling cider, fudge, salsas, barbeque sauces, and much more.

While the physical mill may close for the winter, the new online store ensures that the spirit of Fly Creek Cider Mill lives on year-round. Whether you're a long-time visitor or a new fan, you can still enjoy the mill's delicious products and support their continued success.

Fly Creek Cider Mill is more than just a cider mill; it's a piece of history, a tradition, and a testament to the dedication of the Michaels family. As the seasons change, so too does the mill, adapting and evolving while staying true to its roots. So, while the mill may be closed for a few months, the cider never stops flowing!